between-stars-and-waves

ALT

Ah!

😆

elfwreck

Twitter's faced this law before, and they had strong filters to block Nazi content in Germany. (It was part of how we knew damn well they had the tools to block or remove hate speech... because they did it in countries where it was illegal.)

See this, from 2012:

Twitter Blocks 'Offensive' Accounts In Germany, U.K.; Deletes Tweets In France The micro-blogging site has begun implementing a policy of weeding out and removing offensive content from its site at foreign governments' NPR

It looks like Elon's changes have included removing the anti-Nazi filters from Germany or their moderation team can no longer keep up with reports.

Or both. Both is also likely.

Anyway. The lawsuit is over activity for the last four months, so this isn't "some bits & pieces kept slipping through for the last many years, and we're finally annoyed enough to do something about it."

Twitter Faces Big Fines in Germany for Failing to Pull 'Clearly Illegal' Content Germany could fine Twitter up to €50 million, under the country's Network Enforcement Act for failing to take down incitements of hate, defa PCMAG

Germany’s Federal Office of Justice today announced(Opens in a new window) it had started “fine proceedings” against Twitter for possibly violating the country’s Network Enforcement Act. The law essentially requires social media companies to act within 24 hours to remove “clearly illegal” content after it’s been reported, and within seven days to remove other less-obvious illegal postings. 

24 hours is... not a lot of time, since that includes weekends and the reports may be coming in well outside of US business hours.

But. In the past, Twitter managed them. Of course, operating on a skeleton-crew staff, they may not have 24/7 moderation coverage anymore. And Elon doesn't want content removed because someone thinks it's offensive.

My guess: Germany gets its ruling and Twitter refuses to pay up. They've been skipping a lot of payments recently.

Elon Musk-led Twitter has been sued by at least six companies for failing to pay bills Elon Musk is facing a pile of lawsuits over non-payment to vendors at Twitter. CNBC

And then he starts screaming when every advertiser with an office in Germany pulls their ads under threats from the German government. Oh, and German ISPs will then block Twitter entirely. (Which was the threat that got them to create the anti-Nazi filter in the first place - Twitter wasn't concerned about fines, but they didn't want to be blocked in a substantial portion of the EU.)

mapplestrudel
Inhaltemoderation auf Twitter: „Wir bei HateAid erleben vor allem Willkür“ Auf Twitter floriert die Hassrede. Zum ersten Mal hat nun das Bundesamt für Justiz ein Bußgeldverfahren eingeleitet, das die Qualität der Mo netzpolitik.org

According to netzpolitik.org the fine is up to 5 million €, not 50 million

lady-byleth

To be clear here, the fine isn't what's important, it's the possibility of twitter being blocked completely in Germany

Because many of you won't know this but nazi rhetoric and symbols are highly illegal here, in all forms. A Hitler salute alone falls under two separate laws actually and can get you locked up for 3 years (usage of nazi symbols) or even 5 (hate speech).

So that the German law enforcement clocked this means Musk either has to haul ass or lose an entire market